Welcome to Ice Maker Best! I’m your guide, and I’ve spent years tinkering with, testing, and taking apart every kind of ice maker you can imagine. From countertop companions to under-the-counter workhorses, I’ve seen it all. And let me tell you, the dream of having an endless supply of perfect ice can quickly turn into a nightmare if you pick the wrong machine. That’s why delving into customer reviews before buying an ice maker isn’t just a good idea—it’s your most crucial step. It’s the difference between blissful, chilled drinks and a noisy, leaky paperweight on your counter. Stick with me, and I’ll show you how to read those reviews like a seasoned pro and find the machine that’s truly right for you.
Why Do You Absolutely Need an Ice Maker?
Before we dive into the nitty-gritty of reviews, let’s talk about why you’re even here. Why trade your trusty ice trays for a dedicated appliance? The answer is simple: convenience and quality. An ice maker is a game-changer for so many situations.
- The Entertainer’s Best Friend: Hosting a summer BBQ or a holiday party? The last thing you want is to run out of ice. A good ice maker ensures the drinks keep flowing and your guests stay cool. Reviews often highlight this, with users raving, “This machine saved my party!” or lamenting, “It couldn’t keep up with demand.”
- The Everyday Upgrade: For families, athletes, or anyone who loves a cold beverage, an ice maker eliminates the constant refilling of trays and the dreaded “Who used the last ice cube?” dilemma. It’s about having fresh, clean ice on demand, 24/7.
- The Aficionado’s Choice: Maybe you’re obsessed with that soft, chewable “nugget” ice from your favorite soda shop. Or perhaps you need crystal-clear, slow-melting cubes for your whiskey. A specialized ice maker delivers a specific ice experience that your freezer simply can’t replicate.
The Main Players: Types of Ice Makers on the Market
The term “ice maker” covers a lot of ground. Understanding the basic types is the first step. When you read reviews, you need to know if the feedback applies to the model you’re considering.
Countertop (or Portable) Ice Makers
These are the most popular choice for home use. They’re compact, require no plumbing—just plug it in, add water, and you’re good to go. They’re perfect for apartments, RVs, or for supplementing your freezer’s ice supply.
- What to look for in reviews: Pay close attention to comments about the speed of the first batch, the noise level, and how easy it is to clean. Since their baskets aren’t refrigerated, also look for feedback on how quickly the ice melts and recycles.
Undercounter Ice Makers
These are the big leagues. Installed under your kitchen counter like a dishwasher, they offer a continuous supply of high-quality ice. They require a dedicated water line and a drain, making them a more permanent installation.
- What to look for in reviews: Durability is key here. Look for reviews that are several months or even years old. Comments on installation difficulty, customer service quality for repairs, and the consistency of the ice shape and clarity are gold.
Decoding the Specs: Key Features to Scrutinize in Reviews
Manufacturers love to throw around big numbers and fancy terms. Customer reviews are where you find out what those specs actually mean in a real-world kitchen. Here’s what to focus on.
- Production Capacity (lbs per 24 hours): A spec like “26 lbs per day” sounds like a lot. But reviews will tell you the real story. Does it consistently produce that much? Or does it slow down after a few hours? Look for comments that give you a practical sense of its output for a family or a small gathering.
- Bin Capacity (Storage): This is how much ice the machine can hold at one time. A large production capacity is useless if the bin is tiny. Reviews will often say, “I have to empty the basket every hour,” which is a major red flag if you need a set-it-and-forget-it machine.
- Ice Cycle Time: How long does it take to make one batch of ice? Most countertop models claim 6-10 minutes. Check reviews to see if this holds true over time. A user might mention, “It was fast at first, but now it takes almost 20 minutes.”
- Noise Level: This is one of the most subjective but important factors. One person’s “gentle hum” is another’s “jet engine.” Look for comparisons, like “it’s quieter than my refrigerator” or “I can hear it from the next room.” This context is invaluable.
- Cleaning and Maintenance: Every ice maker needs to be cleaned regularly to prevent mold and mineral buildup. How easy is that process? Reviews are the only place you’ll find honest feedback on self-cleaning functions, drain plug locations, and how hard it is to get into the nooks and crannies.
|
Our Picks for the Best Ice Maker in 2025
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
|
||
| Num | Product | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silonn Ice Makers Countertop, 9 Cubes Ready in 6 Mins, 26lbs in 24Hrs, Self-Cleaning Ice Machine with Ice Scoop and Basket, 2 Sizes of Bullet Ice for Home Kitchen Office Bar Party, Sliver |
|
| 2 | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle, Ready in 6 Mins, 34lbs Per Day, Removable Top Cover, Auto-Cleaning, Portable Sonic Ice Maker with Basket and Scoop, for Home/Party/RV/Camping (Black) |
|
| 3 | EUHOMY Nugget Ice Makers Countertop, Pebble Ice Maker Machine with 35lbs/24H Soft Ice, Self-Cleaning Sonic Ice Maker with Ice Scoop&Basket, Pellet Ice Maker for Home/Kitchen/Office(Stainless Steels) |
|
| 4 | Silonn Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, Pebble Ice Maker with Soft Chewable Ice, One-Click Operation Ice Machine with Self-Cleaning, 33lbs/24H for Home,Kitchen,Office |
|
| 5 | Silonn Countertop Ice Maker, 9 Ice Cubes in 6 Mins, 26 Lbs in 24 Hrs, Compact Ice Machine with Ice Basket & Scoop, 2 Ice Sizes, Self-Cleaning Ice Maker for Home/Party/Office/Bar/Dorm, Black |
|
| 6 | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black |
|
| 7 | Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, Silonn Chewable Pellet Ice Machine with Self-Cleanin Function, 33lbs/24H Portable Ice Makers for Home Kitchen Officce, Black |
|
| 8 | Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact Maker, Ice Making Machine, Black Stainless, Medium |
|
| 9 | Ice Maker Countertop, 9 Cubes Ready in 6 Mins, 26 lbs per Day, Ice Machine with 2 Ice Sizes and Self-Cleaning, Portable Ice Maker with Handle for Home, Kitchen, Camping, RV, Office, Black |
|
| 10 | FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Silver |
|
A Pro’s Guide to Reading Customer Reviews Before Buying an Ice Maker
Okay, you’re ready to start digging. But scrolling through hundreds of reviews can be overwhelming. Here’s my battle-tested strategy for cutting through the noise and finding the truth.
- Look for Patterns, Not Outliers: Ignore the single 1-star review from someone who likely got a lemon and the single 5-star review that just says “Great!” The most valuable information lies in the patterns. Are multiple people mentioning the same strange noise? Are dozens of users praising the ice quality? That’s the stuff to pay attention to.
- Filter by “Most Recent”: A model that was great two years ago might have had a change in manufacturing. Reading the most recent reviews gives you the best picture of the product being shipped today.
- Read the 3-Star Reviews First: This is my secret weapon. The 1-star and 5-star reviews are often driven by extreme emotion. The 3-star reviews are typically more balanced and detailed. They often say things like, “I love the ice it makes, but it’s a pain to clean.” This gives you a realistic view of the pros and cons.
- Translate the Jargon: Users describe problems in everyday language. “It stopped working” is vague. Look for more detail. “The ‘add water’ light is always on even when it’s full” points to a specific sensor issue that might be a common flaw.
- Hunt for Long-Term Durability Clues: Look for reviews titled “6-Month Update” or “Still going strong after a year!” These are pure gold. Anyone can love a machine in the first week. You want to know if it’s built to last.
- Evaluate Customer Service Mentions: When things go wrong, how does the company respond? Reviews that detail interactions with customer support are incredibly telling. A company that stands by its product is a much safer bet.
“The biggest mistake people make is only reading the top five reviews. You have to dig into the middle-of-the-road feedback and look for recurring issues. A single bad unit is a fluke; twenty people complaining about the same pump failure is a design flaw.” – John Carter, Seasoned Appliance Technician
Beyond the Basics: Maintenance and Common Hiccups
Reviews are a great place to learn about the long-term ownership experience. What are the common chores and problems you can expect?
Simple Maintenance Routines Users Swear By
Many positive reviews will include tips. Here’s a checklist of common advice for keeping your machine in top shape:
- [ ] Use filtered or bottled water to reduce mineral buildup.
- [ ] Empty and wipe out the water reservoir weekly.
- [ ] Run a cleaning cycle with a vinegar/water solution or a dedicated descaling solution at least once a month.
- [ ] Wipe down the exterior and the ice scoop regularly.
Common Problems You’ll See in Reviews (and What They Mean)
- “My ice tastes like plastic!”: This is a very common complaint for new machines. Most experienced users will advise running a few cleaning cycles and discarding the first few batches of ice to flush out the system. If reviews mention the plastic taste persists after a month, that’s a red flag for low-quality materials.
- “It’s making a loud grinding/squealing noise.”: This often points to a problem with the motor or the mechanism that harvests the ice. If you see this pop up frequently in reviews for a specific model, steer clear.
- “The ice is wet and melts instantly.”: In a non-refrigerated countertop unit, this is somewhat normal. The key is context. Do reviewers say it’s manageable, or do they say the ice melts into a single giant clump before they can even use it?
The Great Ice Debate: Nugget vs. Cube vs. Bullet
The type of ice a machine makes is a huge factor. Reviews are filled with passionate arguments for each type. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you understand what people are talking about.
| Ice Type | Shape & Texture | Best For | What Reviewers Say |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nugget Ice | Small, soft, chewable pellets | Sodas, iced coffee, cocktails | “The good ice,” “Just like Sonic’s,” “Perfect for chewing” |
| Clear Cube Ice | Solid, square, slow-melting | Whiskey, high-end cocktails | “Crystal clear,” “Doesn’t water down my drink,” “Looks professional” |
| Bullet Ice | Cylinder with a hollow center | General use, blended drinks | “Makes ice fast,” “Good for everyday,” “A little cloudy” |
| Crescent Ice | Half-moon shape | Iced tea, water bottles | “Fits well in glasses,” “Doesn’t clump together as much” |
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How long should a good ice maker last?
A: Based on thousands of user experiences, a quality countertop ice maker should last 3-5 years with proper maintenance. Undercounter models, being more robust, should last much longer, often 7-10 years or more. Reviews are the best indicator of a model’s real-world lifespan.
Q: Are all countertop ice makers noisy?
A: No, but they all make some noise. Expect to hear the fan, the sound of water pumping, and the clatter of ice dropping into the bin. Premium models are often better insulated. Check reviews for specific noise complaints and comparisons to other kitchen appliances.
Q: What is the single most common complaint in ice maker reviews?
A: Besides units that are dead on arrival, the most frequent long-term complaint is that the machine simply stops working after 6-12 months. This highlights the importance of checking customer reviews before buying an ice maker to identify models known for premature failure.
Q: Do I really need a model with a self-cleaning function?
A: While you still need to do some manual wiping, a self-cleaning function makes maintenance much easier by circulating cleaning solution through the internal plumbing. Many reviewers state they would never buy another machine without this feature.
Q: Can I use tap water in my ice maker?
A: You can, but most long-term users strongly recommend against it. Tap water contains minerals that lead to scale buildup, which can clog the machine and affect the taste of the ice. Using filtered or distilled water is the most common tip for extending the life of an ice maker.
Your Ice-Making Journey Starts Here
There you have it—the complete playbook for navigating the world of ice maker reviews. It’s not about finding a “perfect” machine, because one doesn’t exist. It’s about finding the machine whose strengths align with your needs and whose weaknesses you can live with. By learning to read between the lines, focusing on patterns, and understanding what features truly matter, your journey of sifting through customer reviews before buying an ice maker will lead you to the perfect appliance for your home. Now go forth, choose wisely, and may your drinks forever be chilled.